Most meetings in companies are performances.
For example, the weekly meeting is nominally about syncing progress, but in reality it’s a room full of people taking turns chanting scriptures. Whatever has already been written in the weekly report has to be read aloud again in front of everyone. Something that a hundred-word email could explain clearly takes a dozen people a whole morning sitting and listening.
After finally enduring the sutra-chanting conference, the afternoon is at last devoted to discussing project issues. But no sooner has the previous person finished describing mountains of difficulty than the next starts talking about how late they worked overtime—everyone has their own mountains and seas to cross.
Seeing that the project is about to be delayed, everyone moves from insufficient staffing to departmental coordination, from departmental coordination to company strategy, and finally gets torn between Tomson Riviera and Pearl River Palace. By the time someone finally pulls the topic back, it’s almost time to get off work. The leader wraps up by demanding higher efficiency and stronger collaboration; everyone nods and says they will go all out.
A whole day of meetings is held with great vigor, but no one knows what happens to the project next. How hard so-and-so has been working, on the other hand, you have understood clearly.
Everyone is performing effort.
Why is it so difficult to push business forward in meetings? If you want to get your own work done, you inevitably have to use resources from other departments.
To win a client, Sales needs support from Planning and Development to provide solutions and demos. For Planning, they think Sales overpromises and completely ignores delivery. For Development, only confirmed orders are the core interest of their own department.
Everyone wants the business to succeed, but how much should be invested, who pays for that investment, and how much each party can get in the end may not be agreed upon. Everyone has their own hardships and difficulties. If anyone voluntarily gives way, it may mean taking on an extra share of the cost.
These trade-offs of interests should be decided by people higher up. How to adjust the proportion of resource investment and which opportunities should be abandoned cannot be solved by a single sentence about “strengthening collaboration.” But since no matter how much people argue in the meeting, the higher-ups still cannot make up their minds, everyone can only overcome the difficulties again and keep working hard.
If the people below really want to move things forward, they have to coordinate resources and fight for cooperation; they may also have to agree to extra demands in exchange for support. You take on more responsibility, but if things succeed, you may not get commensurate credit. If things go wrong, all the problems may be tied to you. Whoever takes the initiative has to carry several more thankless mountains on their back.
Naturally, most things make no new progress, so the report must be done beautifully. You can’t very well say you didn’t work hard enough, can you? So how many times clients were visited, how many versions the proposal went through, and how late the project team worked overtime all have to be stated clearly. Pile on data and material: no credit, all hard work.
Everyone knows it’s useless, but the attitude must be proper.
You also know these performances are not worth a damn, but you still need to sit upright in the meeting room with a pained, deeply aggrieved look.
Colleagues are all talking about the difficulties they have encountered; everyone expresses understanding but does not directly respond whether they will provide support. You can’t very well say that all these issues were already in the weekly report—can we please skip ahead to the next item? You think it’s a waste of time; others say it’s a problem with your work arrangements.
No one wants to undermine anyone else. Opinions can differ, support can be withheld, but everyone has to acknowledge that the other party has already worked hard. We are all a community of effort.
So you still have to listen to what should be listened to. Others spend time demonstrating their effort, so you have to spend time showing understanding. When it’s your turn, you also have to go through the whole routine. Whether the meeting is useful can be discussed separately; no one can afford to seem out of place.
Even if you still have a pile of things waiting to be coordinated, you can’t chase people for results. After all that busywork, you’ve heard everyone’s difficulties once, and not even half of your own issues are resolved. The absence of support does not mean the work can be left undone. The work is still the same work; when it comes time to report progress, saying you lack people and resources becomes shirking responsibility.
After all, everyone was very proactive in the meeting—so how come things came to a stop when it reached you?
The meetings go on as usual.
The meeting is over, but the resources you wanted are still nowhere to be found, and the disagreements between departments still exist. The leader asks everyone to overcome difficulties, but how the project should move forward ultimately still depends on the people below to figure something out themselves.
Fortunately, everyone is already used to it: today you consult this person, tomorrow you beg that person for help. Little by little, you push the project’s progress forward; if there’s really no other way, you put in a few more overtime hours. There is always a way to help the company overcome the difficulties it has created for itself.
The project is still moving forward after all, which shows everyone’s work is still highly effective. As for why not even half a problem was solved during the meeting, that no longer seems so important.
Of course, on the road to solving problems, new problems always keep coming. Since there are new problems that need coordination, of course there must be more meetings. But no matter how the problems change, the way to solve them is always after the meeting ends and before going to sleep.
Anyway, the project is still being tossed around, and the meetings go on as usual. You have to figure out how to get things done, and you also have to find time to attend one fruitless discussion after another.