Every time the boss says he’s going to crack down on attendance, you know the company is going under.
It’s as if the world has some hidden theorem beyond science. When the boss tells employees that business is tough, it means this year’s raises are canceled; whenever the boss starts policing attendance, the company is doomed; when he holds a big meeting and tells employees to look for problems in themselves, needless to say, a pay cut is coming. If you suddenly see the executives walk out of the boss’s office with grim expressions, wanting to say something but holding back, congratulations—there will most likely be layoffs.
A hundred people have a hundred Hamlets in their hearts, but they share the same boss template.
The most magical thing about this template is that the boss talks only about difficulties encountered in business, but in the end all the changes are to employee compensation.
In a company, most employees do execution-level work. What jobs to take on and what deliverables to provide are all decided by the boss. What employees receive are already-determined requirements and tasks that must be completed. The boss organizes the business; employees are responsible for doing the work well.
If employees have completed their work as required and the company still has no profit, then the boss’s business ability also needs to be reviewed.
But the reality is: if an employee screws up the work, their performance pay is docked; if the boss screws up the business, employee performance pay is still docked.
Limited liability company, unlimited liability employees.
How much you get paid, how much work you do, and how much responsibility you bear—these are basic common sense in a commercial society.
The boss is responsible for organizing resources, using employees’ labor to amplify returns, and while bearing operating risks, earns money from leverage. Management is responsible for judging direction and allocating resources, corresponding to management-position compensation. So when business goes wrong, the first thing to review should be management’s decisions; that is the responsibility corresponding to their compensation.
But many times, they don’t think this is their responsibility. In their view, the direction is set, the resources that could be given have been given, and high-level requirements have been set; if things don’t get done, naturally it’s because the people below didn’t execute well.
Thus, management’s decisions become a premise that needs no review, while employees’ execution must be tested by business results. Employees not only have to do things well; they also have to prove that the leaders’ decisions were right.
So to keep their jobs, employees often have to take on a lot of responsibility outside their positions. If the direction is off, they have to find a way to make the project succeed themselves; if resources aren’t fully provided, they have to coordinate everywhere and find people to help; if there aren’t enough hands, they have to fill in with their own personal time. Problems that should have been solved by management end up as difficulties employees have to overcome.
If it succeeds, the boss is brilliant; if it fails, you have to “reflect” on yourself, look for more problems in yourself, and think about what else you can do for the company.
Paying for the boss’s sense of security.
What more can employees do for the company?
If a business can no longer make money, what’s the point of doing more? Many times, when the boss asks employees to reflect, he is shifting his own responsibility onto them.
Why did a business that used to make money stop making money now? Do customers have more choices, or has the competitive environment changed? Why do customers find the same quote too expensive this year? How should the product direction be adjusted, or what service model should be designed to drive deals?
These are all issues the boss and management need to consider. Responding to changes in the environment is inherently the operator’s job; employees just need to follow along and do the work. The market environment has changed, but the product and service have changed not at all, yet employees are required to grind out higher profits—this is a kind of feudal superstition beyond science.
A business that made money in the past does not mean it will still bring profits to the company in the future. Many people once made a model work and think they’re set for life. The harder business gets, the more tightly they cling to what they know. So past successful experience becomes the path dependency that hinders change today.
This path dependency can only satisfy the boss’s and management’s sense of security. As if as long as the same things can continue, the business is valid, and their value in the company is valid too. As for how much suffering employees have to endure to maintain their sense of security, that is not something they will consider.
If the boss is unwilling to pay the price for change, he makes employees pay the price for his refusal to change.
Employees are the company’s source of profit.
Employees are supposed to be the people who help the company make the business succeed, but when the boss increasingly relies on suppressing employee compensation to maintain profits, this business becomes one where employees lower their compensation in exchange for the right to work.
When the boss raises prices for customers, he still has to shamelessly explain why his stuff is expensive. To get employees to accept a pay cut, all he has to do is repeatedly emphasize how difficult the company is and how bad the employees’ abilities are. The company may not have the ability to make customers pay more, but it is increasingly good at persuading employees to take less pay.
When it makes money, you get a salary; when it doesn’t, you become “one of us” who has to bear operating risks. Employees were originally relying on this job to support themselves, but in the end they have to use their own income to support an unprofitable business.
In the end, employees are the company’s customers.